Skip to content
Free stat checkYour three best numbers, at no cost and no obligation.Get yours
Empty stadium under floodlights at night
Research

Data, not propaganda

The right exposure helps athletes get seen and believe in their own progress. Overexposure adds pressure. These studies guide how we work, so families can decide with evidence instead of hype.

8.1%of high school football players reach NCAA football
83%of coaching staffs researched recruits online (2015)
1,120athletes: when they use social media matters more than how much
351Division I athletes: more NIL commitment, more stress
What we took from it

Six NextRep principles

  1. Findable, not overexposedCoaches search early. An accurate profile and a few quality posts are enough.
  2. Own progress firstMastery is the strongest source of confidence. We show verified improvement over time.
  3. Performance, not imagePhysical self-presentation is the weakest confidence source. We never sell lifestyle or looks.
  4. More than an athleteAn identity built only on sport raises risk. Profiles include academics and interests.
  5. The right levelOnly 3.4% reach Division I. D2, D3, NAIA and junior college are real goals.
  6. Brand later, if everNIL adds stress. Recruiting and confidence come first; NIL is optional and later.
The library

What the studies say

Plain-language summaries in our own words. Each card links to the original source so you can check it yourself.

1 · Exposure and recruiting

Peer-reviewedBigsby, Ohlmann & Zhao · Big Data · 2019

Keeping it 100: Social Media and Self-Presentation in College Football Recruiting

1,792 football recruits (class of 2016), 7,261 offers, 5.5 million tweets

Recruits with an active Twitter presence received more scholarship offers than recruits with no account. Posting about their own athletic success was linked to more offers mainly for lower-rated (0–2 star) recruits. These are associations, not proof of cause.

For NextRep: Being findable matters most for athletes who are not already on recruiters' radar. That is our main audience.

Industry surveyCornerstone Reputation · industry survey · 2015

Cornerstone Reputation College Athletics Survey

About 600 coaches at 300+ Division I, II and III colleges

83% of coaching staffs researched recruits online during the 2013–14 season, and 66% searched as soon as they heard of a recruit. Coaches said mentions of good play and athletic achievements can help a recruit.

For NextRep: Coaches look you up early. A clean, accurate profile is the first impression. (Older survey; platforms have changed since.)

Official dataNCAA Research · updated March 2026 · 2024–25 data

Estimated Probability of Competing in College Athletics

1,029,588 high school football players; 83,794 NCAA football players

About 8.1% of high school football players go on to play at an NCAA school (3.4% Division I, 2.1% Division II, 2.6% Division III). About 1.4% of NCAA football players are drafted by the NFL.

For NextRep: Exposure should aim at the right level, not only Division I. We present every level (D1, D2, D3, NAIA, junior college) as a real opportunity.

2 · Confidence and development

ReferenceBased on Bandura's self-efficacy theory · SAGE

Self-Efficacy (Encyclopedia of Sport and Exercise Psychology)

Reference summary of decades of sport-psychology research

Past performance accomplishments (mastery experiences) are considered the most influential and dependable source of an athlete's confidence, because they are based on the athlete's own experience.

For NextRep: Our posts show an athlete their own real progress. Seeing verified improvement is a mastery experience, not hype.

Peer-reviewed (cited)Vealey et al. · 1998 · as summarized in later peer-reviewed work

Sources of Sport-Confidence in High School Athletes

High school athletes completing the Sources of Sport-Confidence Questionnaire

High school athletes drew confidence mostly from mastery, social support, physical and mental preparation, coaches' leadership and demonstration of ability. Physical self-presentation (how they look) was the least important source.

For NextRep: Confidence comes from skill and support, not image. We highlight performance and preparation, never looks or lifestyle.

Systematic reviewEime et al. · Int. J. Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity · 2013

A systematic review of the psychological and social benefits of participation in sport for children and adolescents

30 studies selected from 3,668 publications

The most common benefits of sport for young people were improved self-esteem and social interaction, followed by fewer depressive symptoms. Team sport was linked to better outcomes than individual activity, likely because of its social nature.

For NextRep: The goal is to keep athletes in sport and connected to their team. Our content celebrates the team, not just the individual.

Peer-reviewedFrontiers in Psychology · 2025

Self-efficacy, psychological resilience and life satisfaction in student athletes

University student athletes

Self-efficacy strongly predicted psychological resilience, and both predicted life satisfaction. Resilience partly explained the link between self-efficacy and life satisfaction.

For NextRep: Building real confidence has value beyond recruiting. It supports well-being whatever level the athlete reaches.

3 · The risks of overexposure

Peer-reviewedBarry et al. · Journal of American College Health · 2022 (online), 2024

Social media engagement, perceptions of social media costs and benefits, and well-being in college student-athletes

1,120 college student-athletes from nine universities

Total screen time was not linked to well-being. Using social media during daily activities was linked to lower self-esteem and more fear of missing out, stress, anxiety and depression. Feeling that social media interferes with life was also linked to worse well-being.

For NextRep: We do the production so athletes do not live on their phones. Fewer, better posts; no pressure to be always online.

Peer-reviewedHughes, Demaray, Skiba & Warriner · J. Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics · 2026

Online Harassment and Mental Health Among Collegiate Student-Athletes

85 Division I athletes at ten Mid-American Conference universities

78% had name-mention alerts turned on. Online harassment was positively linked to depression. The authors recommend pairing visibility with digital safety education and mental health screening.

For NextRep: Visibility needs guardrails. We advise families on privacy settings and keep comments and mentions low-risk.

Peer-reviewedClark et al. · Frontiers in Psychology · 2025

Athletic identity, anxiety, and depression in moderate to highly specialized female adolescent volleyball players

149 female high school volleyball players (average age 16)

High athletic identity, more than specialization or injury, was linked to higher anxiety and depression scores (not at clinical levels). The authors recommend coping skills and interests outside sport.

For NextRep: An athlete is more than a stat line. Our recruiting pages include academics and interests, not only sport.

4 · NIL and brand-building

Peer-reviewedHeinze, Lu, Ren & Soderstrom · J. Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics · 2026

From Field to Marketplace: NIL, Identity Dynamics, and Well-Being Among College Athletes

351 Division I athletes across four major conferences

Greater NIL commitment was linked to a stronger athlete identity and more NIL-related stress. Satisfaction with NIL predicted lower stress. Athletes named limited support, time demands and complex procedures as main stressors.

For NextRep: Brand-building is not free. We focus on recruiting exposure first and treat NIL as a later, optional step.

Peer-reviewedPower, Bredikhina & Paek · J. Issues in Intercollegiate Athletics · 2026

Educating NCAA Student-Athletes to Mitigate Social Media Risks (STORM pilot)

117 student-athletes, two survey waves

A short online training produced significant gains in athletes' perceived knowledge of social media risks, coping strategies, time management and confidence staying safe online. At-risk athletes gained the most.

For NextRep: Education works. Every NextRep package includes a short guide on healthy, safe posting habits.

Last reviewed November 2026. Summaries are for guidance only and are not medical or legal advice. Most studies show associations, not cause and effect.

Free stat check

Find your three best numbers

Send us an official stats link. We reply with the three numbers that would impress a coach, plus a sample post idea.